Jump to content

Suicide: Difference between revisions

From The Austrian Economics Wiki, the global repository of classical-liberal thought
Bridget Ulrich quote
No edit summary
Line 4: Line 4:
==Views on suicide==
==Views on suicide==
[[Timo Virkkala]] argued that suicide is (or can be) a tort against others because it constitutes [[littering]] with one's body, by abandoning it, if one does it carelessly.<ref>{{cite web|author=Virkkala, Timo|title=Body Abandonment|date=30 October 2012|url=http://wirkman.wordpress.com/2012/10/30/death-by-self/}}</ref> [[Thomas Szasz]]'s book ''[[Fatal Freedom]]'' defends every individual's right to choose a voluntary death. [[Peter McWilliams]] writes, "Our culture's taboo against suicide often keeps people who are thinking about suicide from talking about it. By talking about it, people can often get the emotional and psychological support they need to see them through a rough time. When people are afraid to talk about it, the pressures can increase to the point that they actually do something about it. If suicide itself were not forced to be—by law—such a lonely activity, we might have fewer suicides. Even if we did not, however, there is no reason for laws that make one's last moments painful and lonely."<ref>{{cite book|url=http://www.drugsense.org/mcwilliams/www.mcwilliams.com/books/books/aint/3120.htm|title=Ain't Nobody's Business If You Do|chapter=Suicide and Assisted Suicide|author=McWilliams, Peter}}</ref>
[[Timo Virkkala]] argued that suicide is (or can be) a tort against others because it constitutes [[littering]] with one's body, by abandoning it, if one does it carelessly.<ref>{{cite web|author=Virkkala, Timo|title=Body Abandonment|date=30 October 2012|url=http://wirkman.wordpress.com/2012/10/30/death-by-self/}}</ref> [[Thomas Szasz]]'s book ''[[Fatal Freedom]]'' defends every individual's right to choose a voluntary death. [[Peter McWilliams]] writes, "Our culture's taboo against suicide often keeps people who are thinking about suicide from talking about it. By talking about it, people can often get the emotional and psychological support they need to see them through a rough time. When people are afraid to talk about it, the pressures can increase to the point that they actually do something about it. If suicide itself were not forced to be—by law—such a lonely activity, we might have fewer suicides. Even if we did not, however, there is no reason for laws that make one's last moments painful and lonely."<ref>{{cite book|url=http://www.drugsense.org/mcwilliams/www.mcwilliams.com/books/books/aint/3120.htm|title=Ain't Nobody's Business If You Do|chapter=Suicide and Assisted Suicide|author=McWilliams, Peter}}</ref>
==Regulations==
Virtually all suicide methods have a risk of failure, which in many cases can result in serious injury. For example, gunshot or knife wounds (e.g. to the head or wrist, respectively) can result in permanent brain or nerve damage, respectively. ''The Peaceful Pill Handbook'' graded several suicide methods by reliability and peacefulness (of primary importance) and availability, preparation, undetectability, speed, safety, and storage (of secondary importance), concluding that what is needed is a "peaceful pill" — that is, a pill or drink that provides a peaceful, pain-free death at a time of a person's individual choosing; a pill that is orally ingested and available to 'most' people.
Of all the methods considered (including "exit bags" using gases such as nitrogen or helium, which are sometimes recommended by suicide legitimization organizations), pentobarbital, or Nembutal, was identified as the best candidate. However, this particular drug, once widely used as a sleeping pill, has been removed from the market in several countries (such as Australia) and is generally only used for veterinary euthanasia. The most radical pro-euthanasia organizations, such as Exit International, have advocated making pentobarbital available to consumers, especially to those over 50 years of age who do not have a history of [[mental illness]]. Some terminally ill persons have had to make trips to Mexico to obtain pentobarbital.


==References==
==References==

Revision as of 05:37, 27 November 2013

Suicide is the act of intentionally taking one’s own life. Because this definition does not specify the outcome of such acts, it is customary to distinguish between fatal suicide and attempted, or nonfatal, suicide.[1] Bridget Ulrich writes:[2]

With suicide rates soaring, is it any wonder that Liberty is seeing a resurrection within America? These rates indicate an underlying necrosis within our society which we must strive to locate, lacerate and extract. . . . . Activism yields rewards that affect both our communities as well as us personally. It is a medium on which we can add sustenance to our spirits in this age of increasing spiritual vexing/draining. . . . . If we as a society wish to address these rigid statistics, we have to address the hard facts that something is toxic within our society. We absolutely must work to help empower people by showing them how empowering it is to be your own person, own your own life, and be your own advocate. By delegating these roles to the government, we've gotten a lax return on our investment and forgotten how to care and advocate for ourselves. The big government wants us to feel meager and insufficient so that we feel we need an omnipotent force to micromanage our daily lives. Help your neighbors remember their intrinsic divinity. Get out and advocate for the Libertarian ideology. It is the basic fuel for a satiated soul.

Views on suicide

Timo Virkkala argued that suicide is (or can be) a tort against others because it constitutes littering with one's body, by abandoning it, if one does it carelessly.[3] Thomas Szasz's book Fatal Freedom defends every individual's right to choose a voluntary death. Peter McWilliams writes, "Our culture's taboo against suicide often keeps people who are thinking about suicide from talking about it. By talking about it, people can often get the emotional and psychological support they need to see them through a rough time. When people are afraid to talk about it, the pressures can increase to the point that they actually do something about it. If suicide itself were not forced to be—by law—such a lonely activity, we might have fewer suicides. Even if we did not, however, there is no reason for laws that make one's last moments painful and lonely."[4]

Regulations

Virtually all suicide methods have a risk of failure, which in many cases can result in serious injury. For example, gunshot or knife wounds (e.g. to the head or wrist, respectively) can result in permanent brain or nerve damage, respectively. The Peaceful Pill Handbook graded several suicide methods by reliability and peacefulness (of primary importance) and availability, preparation, undetectability, speed, safety, and storage (of secondary importance), concluding that what is needed is a "peaceful pill" — that is, a pill or drink that provides a peaceful, pain-free death at a time of a person's individual choosing; a pill that is orally ingested and available to 'most' people.

Of all the methods considered (including "exit bags" using gases such as nitrogen or helium, which are sometimes recommended by suicide legitimization organizations), pentobarbital, or Nembutal, was identified as the best candidate. However, this particular drug, once widely used as a sleeping pill, has been removed from the market in several countries (such as Australia) and is generally only used for veterinary euthanasia. The most radical pro-euthanasia organizations, such as Exit International, have advocated making pentobarbital available to consumers, especially to those over 50 years of age who do not have a history of mental illness. Some terminally ill persons have had to make trips to Mexico to obtain pentobarbital.

References

  1. "suicide. 2012." Encyclopædia Britannica Online. Referenced 31 October, 2012.
  2. Ulrich, Bridget (November/December 2013), "Libertarianism: Fuel for the Soul", Virginia Liberty (Libertarian Party of Virginia) 
  3. Virkkala, Timo (30 October 2012). "Body Abandonment". http://wirkman.wordpress.com/2012/10/30/death-by-self/. 
  4. McWilliams, Peter. "Suicide and Assisted Suicide". Ain't Nobody's Business If You Do. http://www.drugsense.org/mcwilliams/www.mcwilliams.com/books/books/aint/3120.htm. 

Links